Before you ask social media for Medicare plan recommendations, or enroll based on a neighbor’s advice, here’s what to check first: your doctors, your medications, your pharmacy, and your state’s rules.

Table of Contents

Why You Shouldn’t Choose a Medicare Plan Based on a Neighbor’s Recommendation

Medicare's open enrollment period (or AEP-Annual Enrollment Period) runs from October 15 to December 7. Before asking for plan recommendations on social media, or applying for a plan based on a friend or neighbor saying 'you should get the plan I have', read this first.

But I have a Medicare Supplement plan!

Medicare Supplement plans are standardized, so a "Plan N" with one carrier provides the same coverage as a "Plan N" with another carrier. Depending on your state, you may be able to freely change carriers at any time or during certain eligibility windows. In most states, however, if you are not enrolling in a Medicare Supplement for the first time, you will need to answer health questions and qualify for the new plan. It is important in these states to understand the new plan's eligibility requirements, and to not cancel your current plan until you have confirmation that the new plan is issued.

For the purposes of this article, we are focusing mainly on Medicare Advantage (otherwise known as "Part C") plans which have in-network vs out-of-network benefits, and Prescription Drug Plans ("Part D") plans which have different formulary lists and coverage.

Doctors, Specialists, and Hospitals: Ensuring your providers and preferred facilities are in-network.

It is becoming increasingly more common that doctors and providers are affiliated with one or more locations and/or facilities. When this is the case, it is important to check whether the location where you see the doctor or provider is covered, as coverage can vary by location. Doctors also may not be in-network for all plans with the same carrier. Simply asking, "Do you take ABC Insurance?" is not enough. You will need to check with the carrier that your particular doctor is covered under the plan you select.

It is also important to ensure that the facilities you prefer are covered by your selected plan. If you need to have emergency care, a simple procedure, or a longer stay and would prefer to go to (or prefer not to go to) specific hospitals or facilities, it's important to ensure they are in-network.

If you are currently seeing specialists, you will likely need a referral, and may need to obtain pre-approval before seeing your specialist.

Prescription Drug Coverage

Each carrier has a different formulary list (a listing of covered prescription drugs and what 'tier' they are considered to be, with lower tiers generally having a lower cost). Sometimes these formulary lists have quirks such as covering one form of a medication but not others--i.e., capsules may be covered, but not tablets, or vice versa. Additionally, many plans have step-therapy or prior-authorization requirements for certain medications, which may require you to switch medications to remain eligible for those you are already taking. It's important to know what tier your medications are, and what your out-of-pocket costs are anticipated to be for those medications.

To make things more complicated, not every pharmacy is covered by every plan, and some plans have 'preferred' pharmacies, which you must use to get the lowest possible price for your medication.

Paying Now vs. Paying Later

People have strong opinions about Medicare Advantage plans on both ends of the spectrum--some people love them, and others hate them. In my personal opinion, the reason for such a divide is that people are making decisions without having all of the information. Whether it's a well-meaning neighbor, a captive agent that only sells one product, or a flashy brochure that comes in the mail, Medicare Advantage plans come with a number of benefits, but an arguably equal number of tradeoffs.

Many Medicare Advantage plans have a $0 or low monthly premium, which can be enticing to those who are healthy or on fixed incomes. These plans commonly have high out-of-pocket maximums and may include deductibles (including a prescription drug deductible), copayments, and coinsurance. This means that someone with ongoing health conditions could end up paying significantly more than anticipated.

Medicare Supplements, on the other hand, typically have a higher monthly premiums, but in exchange generally have lower out-of-pocket costs, and more flexibility to see doctors and specialists.

That's not to say one or the other is bad or better than the other, it's a simple matter of picking the right product for your situation, and making sure you understand what your plans coverages and limitations are.

State-specific Quirks

It's important too to ensure you understand how your state's rules apply to your situation. Taking advice or recommendations from folks in another state can result in confusion, particularly if you live in a state like Massachusetts, where we have state-specific Medicare Supplement plans.

Massachusetts

Massachusetts Medicare Supplement plans do not use the standard "A-N Plan" structure. In Massachusetts, we have state specific plans--namely Core, Supplement 1, and Supplement 1A. Supplement 1, just like Plan F, is no longer available to Medicare beneficiaries who became eligible on or after January 1, 2020.

Massachusetts also prohibits using medical underwriting for Medigap (Medicare Supplement) plans, so your health history can't be used to deny you coverage or set your price.

Rhode Island

While RI uses the standard lettered plans, it still has some of its own rules. RI recently expanded the ability for those who meet certain requirements to switch from a Medicare Advantage plan, another Medicare Supplement plan (i.e. a different letter), or another carrier during the Annual Enrollment Period (10/15 - 12/7).

How to determine whether a plan meets your needs

Visit the Medicare.gov Plan Finder. Here you can enter your doctors, providers, and prescriptions, and see what the monthly premiums and out-of-pocket costs would be for each plan.

Speak to a local SHINE counselor (in MA, or SHIP counselor in other states). SHINE can be reached at 1-800-243-4636 (TTY: 711)/SHIP (RI) at 1-888-884-8721 (TTY:711), or through your local Council on Aging or Senior Center. SHINE counselors are usually volunteers who have undergone specialized training to offer free, unbiased help. Annual Enrollment is their busiest season, so availability may be limited; please be patient with them — they are volunteers!

Contact a local, independent broker. Beyond selecting and enrolling in a plan, independent brokers can provide assistance throughout the year with billing and other questions for your enrolled plan. Compensation for independent brokers is built into the premiums regardless of whether you use a broker or enroll directly with the carrier, which means you don't pay any additional fees or costs to use an independent broker. Ask which carriers the broker represents, and exercise caution with 'captive' agents who only represent one carrier, as they can't comparison shop across companies. Look for someone who is both knowledgeable and works with a range of local, regional, and national carriers of both Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans.

The bottom line

I don't want to tell you that your neighbor is wrong, or that you shouldn't listen to their experiences. If they tell you that the customer service for one carrier or another is good or bad, that is good information to have. My advice is just not to enroll in a plan based on someone's recommendation without first doing the work to ensure your doctors, pharmacies, medications, and other facilities are covered by that plan (or speak to a SHINE counselor or independent broker who can do the work for you). Everyone is different; everyone's needs, goals, and budget are different. I personally wish Medicare weren't so complicated, but this is the current system, and until there's a change, we have to navigate it as is. There aren't any one-size-fits-all solutions, and it's important to understand the costs, coverage, and out-of-pocket expenses of your selected plan.